Out of stock for three months, a rating down from 4.4 to 4.1, a fifth less revenue. Thirty days after the relaunch, the same profit at 28% margin instead of 21%, with ad spend from 15% of revenue to 6%. August against August, so the season is the same.
August, year one21% margin, too many campaigns and keywords
Out of stockthree months with nothing to sell
The relaunchCampaign Architect, then the rules switched on
30 days laterthe margin had moved
August, year two28% margin, the same profit on a fifth less revenue
30 daysthe same month, a year apart: the season is the same
30 days from the relaunch to the result. The comparison is August against August, a year apart, so the season is the same.
The journey
Not a year's work. 30 days from the relaunch.
Seven steps, in the order they happened. The year between the two figures is only the comparison: the same month, so the season is the same.
01
It started bloated.
Too many campaigns for one product, far too many keywords across them, budget and data spread thin. Then three months out of stock, with nothing to sell.
Campaigns and keywords · one productbefore and after
five campaigns, a few keywords each, every keyword in one place with all of its data
02
Campaign Architect rebuilt it, lean.
At the relaunch, from our own search term reports: fewer campaigns, fewer keywords. Every irrelevant term went in as a phrase negative, in every campaign. Every exact keyword got an exact negative everywhere else, so its data landed in one place.
Irrelevant terms
from the search term reports, negated as phrase, everywhere
cheapdiyreplacement lid
Campaign A
cheapdiyreplacement lid
Campaign B
cheapdiyreplacement lid
Campaign C
cheapdiyreplacement lid
Campaign D
cheapdiyreplacement lid
Exact keywords
negated in every other campaign
Campaign A
insulated bottle 32oz
Campaign B
insulated bottle 32oz
Campaign C
insulated bottle 32oz
Campaign D
insulated bottle 32oz
one campaign, whole picture
03
Bid rules priced every keyword, every week.
Our target ACoS was 20 to 30%. Three rules, one per tier outside it, all on the same condition: at least 15 clicks since the last adjustment. Only the ACoS threshold changed between them.
Bid rules · the ladder we run15+ clicks since last adjustment · weekly
ACoS under 20%Raise 10%
20 to 30%Leave alone
30 to 40%Lower 10%
Over 40%Lower 20%
04
Negation caught the terms that clicked and never sold.
With less volume to work with, every wasted click mattered more. Recommended first, approved by us.
Negation · recommended, then approved30 days · demo data
Search termClicksOrdersSpend
cheap plastic bottleAuto · Loose match
14
0
$17.92
ApproveDismiss
water bottle for dogsAuto · Close match
11
0
$12.10
ApproveDismiss
bottle rocket kitBroad · Head terms
19
0
$21.35
ApproveDismiss
05
Harvesting promoted the winners.
The terms that kept converting got their own exact keyword as they appeared, with an exact negative in every source campaign.
Harvesting · automatic3+ orders · demo data
insulated water bottleAuto · 5 orders
HarvestingHV
Exact keyword created · negated in 3 source campaigns
Applied
steel bottle with strawBroad · 4 orders
HarvestingHV
Exact keyword created · negated in 2 source campaigns
Applied
bottle for hikingPhrase · 3 orders
HarvestingHV
Exact keyword created · negated in 3 source campaigns
Applied
06
Budget rules funded the winners.
Campaigns that were capped and converting got more budget before they ran out. Campaigns spending their budget badly got less.
Out of stock for three months, rating down from 4.4 to 4.1, a fifth fewer units. Thirty days after the relaunch, with the restructure done and the rules running: the same profit at 28% margin instead of 21%, with ad spend from 15% of revenue to 6%. August against August, so the season is the same. The Shopkeeper rows are below.
Product BProfit margin
21%28%
Same profit on a fifth less revenue. In a worse year.
Before21%
After28%
Revenue£3,432 → £2,679−22%
Profit£725 → £757+4%
ACoS35% → 19%−16 pts
TACoS15% → 6%−9 pts
30 daysfrom the relaunch to this marginAug to Augthe same month a year apart, so the season is the same
Out of stock for three monthsRating dropped from 4.4 to 4.1A fifth less revenue · still the same profit
The source: the same Shopkeeper product row, a year apart, in presentation modeAugust, year one · 232 units · £3,432 revenue · £725 profit · 21% margin · 35% ACoSAugust, year two · 180 units · £2,679 revenue · £757 profit · 28% margin · 19% ACoSPresentation mode hides the product. The stock figure at the left of each row was taken the same day and matches: the same listing.
Product anonymised. The result is ours, from our own account; the rule visuals use demo data.